black blue and yellow textile

The Meat Trap

Imagine still clinging to a pacifier—pathetic, right? Yet humanity clings to one: meat.

After the Flood, the Creator permitted Noah to eat meat.

But was this permission a concession—or a test?

Because if taking a life for pleasure was a concession, the Creator's moral values would be called into question.

The Creator is a builder and therefore constructive. His moral values are beyond our imagination. He is too good to design a world where weak animals become food for humans or wild beasts. Even thinking that He would truly approve of Noah taking a life for pleasure is an affront to Divine Justice.

The Creator built the world on the principle of mutual benefit; otherwise, it would not be a fair creation.

How could this permission be a concession when it offered no mutual benefit?

How could it be a concession when the Creator had appointed Adam to lead and protect the animal kingdom?

How could it be a concession when the Creator knew about the law of "Cause & Effect"* and that stronger animals would mirror Noah's behavior and begin killing for food?

After all, He had warned Adam and Chava that nature learns and follows.


Noah had everything he needed to eat. He even made wine. He had no reason to seek additional pleasure he did not need at the cost of morality.

Therefore, His permission was not a compromise—it was a profound moral test:

The Meat Trap

By making meat available to Noah, the Creator challenged his ability to exercise self-control and resist temptation.

Noah mistook availability for a concession rather than recognizing it as a test of his power to choose.

But the man entrusted with preserving animal life chose to kill for meat, changing his own nature.

As a result, the animal population declined. Even worse...

Because of the law of "Cause & Effect," when Noah changed his nature, the animals also changed theirs.

Powerful creatures mirrored his behavior, awakening predatory instincts in animals that had originally sustained themselves on plants.

Animals that should have been multiplying after the Flood now faced predators, disrupting the principle of mutual benefit and threatening their ability to reproduce and flourish.


Because Noah failed his test, Divine Justice stepped in. Through his son, Noah faced karmic consequences—a parallel struggle in his own ability to multiply and flourish.

This consequence reveals why the Creator's permission to eat meat was a moral test—not an endorsement of killing animals for food.

Noah's story teaches that can does not mean should, and that humanity must consider morality before killing animals to indulge in meat,
even if the Creator said we can.

Most importantly, we learn that killing animals limits our own population growth.

In other words, taking advantage of our power over the weak invites karma.


Meat — The Pacifier of Humanity

Before Noah tasted meat, he had no craving for it. But once he discovered its pleasure, humanity developed a craving for meat.

Because Noah revealed his weakness, the Creator allowed humanity to continue consuming meat as a temporary concession to help build emotional strength—much like a parent gives a newborn a pacifier for comfort.

But no parent allows a child to cling to a pacifier forever.

That is why the Creator removed meat from the Israelites' diet after the Exodus.

The goal was to develop self-control, not to remain dependent on meat.

Even though the Creator, out of kindness, permitted meat consumption on special occasions, it does not mean we should take advantage of it and disregard our limits.

The Creator's kindness should not be mistaken for approval of our weaknesses.

When the Israelites complained and demanded meat, the Creator permitted it as a temporary concession when their cravings became intense or uncontrollable—much like a parent allowing a grown child to cling to a pacifier because the child cannot let go.

However, neither concession was ever an endorsement of meat as a dietary staple.

True strength is not the absence of desire, but the ability to control it.

During the time of sacrificial offerings, this self-mastery was essential. Certain sacrifices required eating meat for spiritual elevation, and the people had to fulfill that requirement without allowing it to weaken their self-control.

Beyond teaching self-control, the Creator also taught us compassion for animals.

Before the Exodus, the Creator instructed every Jewish family to select a lamb or goat, keep it under their care for four days, and then sacrifice it and place its blood upon their doorposts. Keeping an animal close for four days naturally fosters an emotional bond, transforming livestock into a companion and making the eventual sacrifice more difficult.

Through this commandment, the Creator delivered a profound message: if humans can form an emotional attachment to an animal in just four days, surely the mother of all beings, who gave birth to animals by divine design, shares a far greater bond with them.

Following the Exodus, the Creator sealed this lesson with a broad mandate—"Thou Shalt Not Kill"**—to protect animals too, affirming that their lives matter.

Yet despite forty years of Divine Justice's efforts to free Noah's offspring from their dependence on the meat-pacifier and restore the world's balance of mutual benefit, we continue to offer weak justifications for indulging in meat.

Noah's punishment and the restriction of meat after the Exodus proved that killing animals for food is an immoral act against Divine Justice—one that also forces the animal kingdom to mirror our behavior and suffer.

Now, let us face the truth behind these justifications:

1. Animals Are Not Plants

Saying animals are plants is the same as saying we are plants. We did not travel from another planet to Earth; we share a common origin with animals, born from the very same Earth.

They share our blood and life force, possessing a sacred connection to human life.

The role of animals as potential sacrifices for our sins demonstrates their value as substitutes for human life; plants can never pay that price.

Adam's naming of animals reveals the close bond between humans and animals, much like how we name our own children. He never named plants.

The Creator appointed Adam to rule over the animal kingdom, not over plants. After all, He designated plants as food for both humans and animals, not as flesh.

2. The Lie of Nutritional Necessity

Science consistently confirms that plant-based and vegetarian*** diets are healthier and more sustainable. These wholesome, nutritious foods require no killing and remain abundantly accessible.

The Creator emptied His celestial refrigerator, providing His guests on Earth with a wide variety of foods—more than enough to sustain human strength in any environment.

Even during their forty-year training, when the Israelites lacked the food choices we enjoy today, they fought and won battles without eating meat.

This proves we do not need the energy of dead flesh to survive our physical or spiritual struggles.

3. The Illusion of Spiritual Elevation

We often hear that slaughtering and eating an animal "elevates" it.

Do we apply this logic to a lamb killed by a lion for food?

According to the law of "Cause & Effect," a lion preying on a lamb reflects our own choice to kill for food.

Could we elevate that tragedy too?

True spiritual elevation cannot stem from harming other beings. If we refuse to recognize this reality, in what language must the Creator communicate this law to us?

Immorality can never be elevated. We cannot fuel spiritual growth through a corrupted act and then thank the Creator for it.

Broken morality is a broken vessel; it cannot hold holy energy.

Consuming an animal under the guise of "elevating" it only degrades our souls. We become what we eat, absorbing lower, animalistic traits, betraying our spiritual purity, and poisoning our own nature.

For these reasons, theories such as the Arizal's "elevation of holy sparks" through kosher slaughter are fundamentally destructive.

What happens to the holy sparks in billions of kosher animals not consumed by observant Jews?

What happens to the holy sparks in non-kosher animals that observant Jews cannot consume?

Are they left spiritually stranded?

Focusing on a preferred subset of nature cannot solve cosmic problems that may never have existed.

More importantly, no theory can alter the natural order or override the law of "Cause & Effect." So...

How could he be right?

If his theory were true and slaughter could elevate animals, the Creator would not have punished Noah for changing the natural order, nor would He have punished the Erev Rav for craving flesh while discouraging meat consumption during the Israelites' forty years of training.

Most importantly, inventing spiritual tasks to justify an uncommanded act mirrors the fatal mistake of Aaron's sons, who brought unauthorized fire before the Creator and paid with their lives.

4. The Delusion of "Honoring Shabbat" with Meat

We honor Shabbat when we don't dine on animal flesh.

During the forty-year training, the Creator did not permit the Israelites to eat meat on this holy day.

We cannot call Shabbat a day of rest while disturbing the rest of nature.

We are called to be holy, a state that requires spiritual strength, not the desire for slaughter.

This sacred day is meant to offer a taste of the "World to Come," where there is no killing.

The taste of meat is not the taste of that world.

5. The Fallacy of the Kosher List

Kosher laws were never an endorsement of meat consumption but a concession for those struggling to control their cravings.

The Justification Trap

For thousands of years, our sages have failed to recognize the law of "Cause & Effect," yet they claim greater insight than Moses himself—the prophet who recognized that meat was never intended to be a dietary staple.

The Creator never ordained such justifications in the Torah or the Oral Torah. They were fabricated to excuse the habit of eating meat.

The restriction of meat after the Exodus proves its destructive nature. Ignoring this lesson insults the Creator's wisdom and recalls the "Graves of Cravings," where many perished because of their desire for flesh.

Justifications are distractions that keep humanity clinging to the meat-pacifier.

But how can we claim to have a relationship with the spiritual world while remaining attached to the physical world through our cravings?

As revealed in Jacob's dream, our strength serves as the ladder connecting the physical and spiritual worlds. Our strength maintains that relationship, while our attachment to physical pleasures weakens it.

We cannot climb the spiritual ladder while allowing physical pleasures to control us.

Without mastering our behavior, ritual prayers alone cannot elevate us to the spiritual level of angels.

The Creator's Property

Moral values are like the property of the Creator. When we violate His moral values, we trespass upon His property.

The Flood reveals how seriously the Creator takes this ownership.

He judged and destroyed the world before delivering any formal law, demonstrating that He expects a fundamental sense of righteousness from humans.

Trust that the Creator is kind and holds nothing against animals. He never intended them to be used for food.

Forcing beings that desire life and resist slaughter to become our dinner is a direct betrayal of the Creator.

Indeed, reciting blessings over food that causes the animal kingdom to suffer is not appreciation; it is manipulation.

True Elevation

True elevation happens when we master our own behavior, not at the dinner table.

The law of "Cause & Effect" dictates that when we master our behavior, animals mirror that change and become elevated too.

This means true elevation comes from changing our own nature, not from killing animals to elevate "holy sparks" through kosher slaughter, as proposed by the Arizal's theory.

By mastering our behavior, we elevate every animal—kosher and non-kosher alike—not merely a preferred subset of nature that cannot solve cosmic problems that may never have existed.

Most importantly, when we stop eating meat, animals will mirror that shift and stop killing for meat too.

Just as animals became carnivores because of us, they can become herbivores once again.

Nature Is Our Mother

Nature is the mother of all living beings. Humans and animals share the same mother, making us earthly kin.

The only difference between us and animals is the holy soul that sets us apart; without that soul, we would be just like our earthly kin.

By eating animals, we consume the children of the very mother who gave birth to and sustains our own physical bodies.

By divine decree, the Creator appointed us as their guardians, not their predators.

Instead of embracing this responsibility, humanity fell into an endless cycle of justifying predation.

According to global agricultural data, over two billion animals are slaughtered weekly for human appetite.

Several types of creatures are baked, roasted, or broiled alive in ovens.

Millions, if not billions, of sea creatures are boiled alive.

And millions of animals are hunted.

We have turned the world into a holocaust for the animal kingdom.

Yet we fail to recognize the pain and suffering we are causing to our earthly kin.

The Broken Cycle

Consuming fruits and vegetables is a profoundly constructive act.

When we eat the harvest, we participate in a sacred cycle of sustenance: what we do not consume returns to the earth, nourishing the soil and the very trees that feed us.

This divine cycle provides mutual benefit to living beings and the earth.

No such harmony exists in the slaughter of animals.

Eating meat breaks the cycle, offering humans fleeting sensory pleasure while bringing destruction to the animal kingdom and ourselves.

It is a dead end—there is no mutual benefit and no cycle.

The Natural Order

Before the Fall, the original natural order was for humans and animals to live forever. Earth was their intended eternal home.

Therefore, we cannot truly desire life while taking animals' lives and changing the original setting of creation.

By destroying animal life, we contradict our own desire to return to that eternal state.

We are actively working against our own will.

Noah's Warning

The Creator does not desire a WEAK nation ADDICTED to meat.

He did not spend forty years training the Israelites to become STRONG only for those efforts to be dismissed as meaningless.

Our continued justifications keep us trapped in the "Meat Trap." They failed to prevent Divine Judgment in the past, and they will not prevent it in the future.

As Noah's history warns us, causing a decline in animal populations invites karma.

— Bahram Cohanfard

Direct Link to This Page: TheMeatTrap.com

* The Law of "Cause & Effect"

The law of "Cause & Effect" dictates that nature, as the female aspect of creation, follows human behavior.

Because nature learns and follows, the Creator warned Adam and Chava not to eat the forbidden fruit. He knew that if they failed or showed weakness, nature would imitate their behavior and ultimately be doomed.

Animals, as a major part of nature, mirror human behavior.

This also explains how Bilaam's donkey learned to speak by following Bilaam, who possessed an extraordinary power of speech.

Read the full analysis: Cause & Effect

** The Commandment "Thou Shalt Not Kill"

While the commandment "Thou Shalt Not Kill" protects animals, bringing them as offerings or for higher constructive purposes commanded by the Creator is permitted.

Under certain conditions, consuming the offered meat is necessary for spiritual elevation.

*** Vegetarian Diets and Animal Products

Although cruelty to animals is unacceptable, consuming animal products is permitted when the owners legally own the livestock.

Those concerned about cruelty can raise animals safely in their own backyards.

Furthermore, unfertilized eggs contain no developing life and will never hatch.

A Note to Religious Leaders

Please bear in mind that if you are a religious figure, you are the primary teacher and role model for your community.

Leadership carries a heavy responsibility.

When those in power mislead their communities, they bear the burden of the sins committed by those who follow them.

© 2026 Star of Unity. All Rights Reserved.